No valid email recipients were selected

[Stranger]

Why does the site generate email template #12 (No valid email recipients were selected.) when valid employers are to be sent applications.

I have a posting listed where the employer wants applications through the site, (The "Recommended" Radio button) and they are not getting emails. Even though the applicant gets an email that says it was received. I know the employers are not getting them because she called me to complain.

I have been tearing my hair out for a week trying to figure this out.

Below is a screen shot of the email list queue.

Any help is appreciated.

Thanks.